So I'm up at dawn, puttin' on my shoes. I just wanna make a clean escape; I'm leavin', but I don't know where to.
- Bright Eyes
::   Blog  ::   Photos  ::   Europe  ::   Books  ::   Articles  ::   Links  ::   Friends  ::   Combo Feed  ::   Mobile  ::    
Submit a story!
Need Help?

Powered by FeedBlitz

Most Popular
An Experiment in Porn
Download This American Life Episodes
Fuck For Forest
Carnival Of The Green #18
Japan and Atomic Bomb Effects

Random Entries:
One Day of War
Secret US Plans For Oil Sparks Neocon vs. Big Oil Fight
How long will a draft card burn in open air?
Synesthaesia: 'Seeing Colors,' 'Tasting Words'
Bush must know better than the authors

World Food/Slow Food
Globalization of Food and Agriculture
NAIS? Ridiculous.
Jalapenos and Salmonella - Same Old Story?
The Effects of Globalization on Developing World Agricultural Systems
GB #7 - Pesticide Contamination
London Restaurants

Recent Comments:
Industrial Agriculture and Vertical Integration
Redefining Recession To Fit Your Agenda
Obama Winning Electoral Votes and McCain Gasping
Pull Out
Obama / Biden vs. McCain
Add me to your buddy list Send me an instant message
Link to Me!
george-at-dirtygreek.org george-at-dirtygreek.org



My Photos
Gallery RSS
My Flickr Photos
Syndicate Me!

Locations of visitors to this page
Register to Vote!
Dirty Greek - School Idiocy
  Religion : School Idiocy
You are NOT on the DirtyGreek.Org homepage. Please CLICK HERE to go there.

From Pharyngula:
"A high school student loans a friend, another high school student, his copy of The God Delusion. Two things happen: the friend's father loses his cool and complains to their school, and a school administrator suggests that this was an establishment clause violation. And this was at a school that allowed the Gideons to distribute bibles in the parking lot!
Believe it or not, I'm not so worried about the religion/atheism aspect of this story, though it is important. I'm worried about this bit:
"She told me that in loaning a religious book to another student, I was promulgating my religious beliefs and forcing the school into an establishment clause violation.

WHAT?!

This kid is an Atheist and I am an Atheist and this book is about Atheism. There doesn't seem to be much "promulgation" there. The God Delusion is also not a religious book. I explained to her that Atheism is not a religion, and so the topic of the book is more akin to philosophy and science. One other thing I don't understand is how what goes on between students violates a clause that states the government cannot sponsor a religion. If the school was handing out The God Delusion, it could be seen as an establishment clause violation, but not if it was solely between students.

She also said that since the book was not in line with the school's curriculum, it was inappropriate for school. I then asked her what she meant by this: if I were to be reading it by myself on campus, would I be breaking a rule? According to her, yes. My English class is not allowed to read Grapes of Wrath because it was deemed unsuitable for non-AP classes by the school board. I happen to be a Steinbeck fan. I asked her if it would be inappropriate to read Grapes of Wrath in school. Her answer was, in my case, yes.
Better empty the library of all books that aren't in line with the curriculum!

Now, obviously, the establishment cause DOES prevent a school from promoting any religion or lack thereof. It does not, however, prevent students from expressing their own religious views to each other. At least, that is, as long as they aren't disrupting class time to do so. There are student religious organizations and student atheist organizations all over the country, and those are perfectly legal. In fact, this is one of the things that annoys me the most about religious people when they discuss "lack of prayer in school." They're always harping on the idea that schools don't allow students to pray, even though they certainly do.

In fact, the only establishment clause violation I can see here is a school telling a student that he cannot express his own lack of religious views to another student.
Posted By George on 12/07/2006 @ 04:01 | Link and Discuss (0) | More
Share And Enjoy: Post To Del.icio.us Post To Socialposter.com Post To Digg Post To Furl Post To Reddit Post To Technorati Post To Blinklist Post To Stumbleupon Post To Twitter Post To Google Bookmarks Post To Pownce Post To NewsVine Post To Microsoft Live Email To A Friend


My Related Posts: Evangelicals Decide Not To Fight Global Warming // New Daniel Quinn Book // Someone Please Run // Donors Choose Challenge // National Forests To Be Sold To Pay For Schools //
No Comments
Name
Email
Subject
  Security Image
 
Comment